You’ve built an email list. You’ve set up instant sign-up confirmation emails. And now you’re beginning to compile regular campaign newsletter content.
As you dive in, you may be wondering: what are the best practices to keep in mind for campaign newsletters?
Many political campaigns send standard run-of-the-mill campaign updates while others only focus on asking for donations.
But what does the data say? Neither of these approaches are optimal for a Republican campaign that intends to build a newsletter that drives fundraising and shifts the electoral landscape.
A successful political email leverages current events and real-world campaign deadlines to engage readers. And the key to conveying urgency in your campaign fundraising asks is authenticity.
Part of building an authentic, urgent email fundraising approach involves sending messages that often don’t ask for donations at all. Optimal Republican newsletter content is a balancing act between asking for donations often enough to make a difference and not asking too often where subscribers think, “Oh great, just another fundraising email.” When subscribers feel candidates are only in it for their money, they unsubscribe, ignore, and begin to resent the emails.
When leveraged strategically, email newsletters can be a powerful way to drive fundraising and supporter engagement. Here, Spark provides six reasons that Republican campaigns should be using urgent, authentic, and timely language and CTAs tied to campaign deadlines and current events in every newsletter send.
Reason #1: Appealing to Donor Psychology Can Help Drive Support
Campaigns must drive fundraising to keep their political momentum. Yet, there are right and wrong ways to do it. Republican campaigns can leverage donor psychology by tapping into what motivates supporters to give.
Donors are often more emotional about particular issues than they are about any particular political campaign or candidate. Campaigns will find tying fundraising asks to the emotional atmosphere of the political climate is a more effective strategy than simply requesting that subscribers support a candidate.
Campaigns should take the time to discover what their supporters like most about Republicans’ stances on issues and dislike the most about the Left’s approach, as these strongly held positions are more likely to lead supporters to take action. Then, use this supporter input to craft messaging that shows how their support directly can help with the issues they care about most.
Reason #2: Real Actionable Timelines Increase Response Rates
Urgency for urgency’s sake feels cheap and degrades supporter sentiment.
Instead, connect your messaging to actual campaign deadlines. Whether the campaign is in the process of collecting signatures or buying ads, you can share this information with your newsletter subscribers and connect it to a fundraising ask.
The deadlines of the election cycle are ideal opportunities to communicate urgently with subscribers. Use the newsletter to make authentic time-sensitive fundraising pushes instead of engineered promotions with artificial urgency.
Reason #3: Capitalizing on Current Events Encourages Donor Engagement
To be effective, newsletters cannot be templated copy that is scheduled to send weeks in advance. Instead, newsletter language should tap into current events. The emotional and sensationalized current events of the political climate are opportunities for clever Republican campaigns to drive fundraising. When stories break that concern Republican voters, that presents a window of opportunity for campaigns to garner support.
Voters will often feel much more strongly about current events than any particular campaign. Candidates anchoring themselves to these events allows supporters to know that they are working to solve the issues that matter most to potential donors.
Reason #4: Building Broader Campaign Momentum Should Go Beyond Cash
Campaigns mixing non-fundraising newsletters with urgent, relevant fundraising sends can create a sense of community. Rather than being just another politician soliciting donations, leveraging your email list strategically creates a larger political movement.
By signing up for your newsletter, subscribers have already demonstrated their interest in supporting the candidate. Don’t let that support go to waste by treating subscribers like an afterthought or only messaging them when it’s time to ask for money.
Effective, engaging Republican campaigns generate a grassroots political community and movement through their newsletter. Whether they donate or not, connecting authentically with these subscribers makes them more likely to advocate for the candidate on social media and in their community.
Reason #5: Targeting Loyal Bases Help Drive Repeat Donations
Republican campaigns can segment their email lists to target valuable support bases while decreasing the risk of donor-fatigue. Thinking strategically, campaigns can segment past-donors for urgent pushes along deadlines requesting additional support.
At the same time, campaigns can exclude recent donors from these same pushes to lower the risk of fatiguing their email list.
Because donating in the past makes any given subscriber more likely to donate in the future, campaigns are wise to include them in relevant, urgent fundraising pushes while remaining cognizant of the risks associated with asking the same subscriber for money too many times.
Reason #6: You Can Make Subscribers Feel Part of “Insider Circle”
Republican campaigns can use their email list and newsletter to build a community of “insiders.” By keeping subscribers up-to-date on campaign deadlines and the electoral process, campaigns show their supporters that they are valued members of their political movement.
By including authentic content and timely insider scoop, campaigns can build a political movement that is bigger than just fundraising. When subscribers feel that they are part of the candidate’s exclusive, valued support base, they will be more likely to support the campaign in material and immaterial ways.
Start Winning With Email Now
Are you looking for more help with creating a campaign newsletter that’s part of a winning Republican campaign digital strategy?
Email Spark. Spark is an alliance of technologists and builders helping campaigns and causes win for the Right.
Plus, be sure to subscribe below for the latest data and transparent insights that are shaping the digital electoral battlefield.